Can you imagine doing all the work of a fundraiser (the flyers, the reminders, the “hey everyone go eat burritos tonight” posts) and then getting a check for two dollars?
Yeah.
That happened to my PTO.
And it’s exactly why we need to talk about restaurant fundraisers today.
Here’s the thing nobody tells you when you first start scheduling spirit night restaurant fundraisers.
Some restaurants treat your fundraiser as a genuine investment in the community.
Others treat it as a one-way street where your PTO does all the work and they keep as much of the money as they can get away with.
I know that sounds judgmental.
It’s also just true in some cases, (maybe unintentionally, but it doesn’t hurt your PTO any less).
The Real Problem with a Lot of Restaurant Fundraisers
Some restaurants only give you a percentage of sales from customers who remember to show a flyer or mention the fundraiser out loud.
That sounds fine on paper.
In practice, it’s a mess.,
A lot of families walk in, order their food, and never think to say “hey, we’re with the school.”
So all that traffic your PTO generated just… disappears into regular sales.
No credit, no percentage, nothing.
And then there’s the other issue, which is honestly worse.
A lot of restaurants don’t have their act together internally.
The manager forgets to tell the staff working that night.
It never gets put on the schedule.
So even when families do mention the fundraiser, nobody records it.
My Burrito Shop Story
This actually happened to me with a large national burrito and taco chain.
As Fundraising Chair, I scheduled a fundraiser night with them and I was excited because they were a popular choice for our middle school crowd.
I really thought this would be a solid middle school fundraiser for us that we could repeat a few times a year.
But the next day, I got an email from their fundraising coordinator saying, “sorry, you didn’t hit the minimum sales threshold.“
I pushed back immediately.
I’d already had a teacher reach out to tell me she went in, ordered, told the cashier she was there with our PTO, and got a look like she had three heads.
Nobody knew what she was talking about.
When she insisted they record it, the manager gave her a discount instead.
She just wanted her purchase to count toward the restaurant spirit night.
Same night, I was working our high school concession stand, so my husband went to pick up dinner for the family instead.
Exact same experience.
No one knew about the fundraiser.
No one had been trained on how to log it.
He walked out with a 30 percent discount and zero dollars credited to our PTO.
So I went back to the restaurant’s fundraising coordinator with our experience.
She said she’d look into it.
Two days later…
“Oh, you know what, you did have enough sales. We just didn’t look in the right places.”
Girl, what?
But we got a check for eighty dollars.
I know for a fact many more people showed up than that check reflected, but $80 beats nothing.
Lesson learned!
It was the last time we scheduled a restaurant fundraiser with this place.
Why This Isn’t Really Your Fault
It’s genuinely unfair.
Your PTO does all the legwork, all the publicity, all the reminders, and then the restaurant can’t hold up its end because their own team wasn’t set up to capture the sales correctly.
So here’s what I’d encourage you to look for instead.
The Better Model: A Flat Percentage of All Sales
We have a pizza shop (technically a chain, but it’s the local franchise making this call) that gives a healthy 20% of all sales during a set window, 4-8 pm, no flyer required, no mention required.
That’s fair.
That’s a real fundraiser.
The result? Every single month, my PTO gets a check somewhere between two hundred fifty and four hundred fifty dollars.
That’s a massive difference compared to the burrito shop’s eighty dollar check for what was probably a similar or bigger turnout.
Unsurprisingly, this pizza shop is now my family’s number one go-to.
We order more than once a month, and a big part of that is loyalty.
They’re generous with us, so we’re generous right back even though we have a slew of other pizza joint options.
The pizza shop doesn’t limit themselves to fundraising for one group either.
Band boosters, orchestra boosters, athletic boosters… they’ll do a night for pretty much anyone.
I think they understand something a lot of restaurants miss: this is constant promotion inside a community full of pizza-eating families.
It’s smart business, not just charity for the sake of a tax write off.
My Advice for Your Next Restaurant Fundraiser
Be cautious about any deal where only “mentioned” or “flyer-shown” sales get counted.
So much can go wrong on the restaurant’s end, and none of it is something you can control.
Sure, some nights genuinely have low turnout.
I get that.
But I’ve had more than one restaurant tell me we had “one customer” out of a school with a thousand kids enrolled.
I know for a fact staff members plan their dinners around fundraiser nights specifically because it’s an easy win… no cooking, and they get to support the PTO and the school.
One person walking through the door on fundraiser night?
I don’t buy it.
And eventually, I just stopped scheduling with that restaurant.
It wasn’t worth anyone’s time.
So next time you’re setting up a restaurant fundraiser, ask the flat percentage question up front.
It could be the difference between a two dollar check and a four hundred dollar one.
Watch this
More PTO Fundraising Resources
Ready to dive more into the work of PTO and school fundraising, but wish you could have a plan of action ready at your fingertips?
Time to learn more about the Fundraising Success Kit!
It’s never been easier to hold highly profitable school fundraisers using these customizable strategies and step by step plans that work for every type of parent group, and any type of fundraiser, from a traditional catalog to A-thon Fundraisers and everything in between.
This resource is guidance plus a complete plan walking through the entire process of fundraising for your school, including a publicity plan, templates, forms and a planner kit to help you get outrageously organized in a snap!
The Organized Leader Bundle: All you’re missing is the right set of tools to be an effective, confident and knowledgable leader! Picture your entire board:
… Knowing exactly what to do … Having plug and play strategies and systems to get every aspect of your PTO organized … Working as an organized team, reaching all your goals and then some! This bundle combines essential officer success and binder kits, customized for each role:
- President’s Success Kit (Planner + Agenda Template + President’s Insider’s Guide)
- Treasurer’s Success Kit (Planner + Editable templates + Treasurer’s Insider’s Guide)
- Secretary’s Success Kit (Planner + Newsletter template, Calendar Template + more)
- Fundraising Success Kit (Planner + Strategy Guide + A-thon Kit + Fundraising Insider’s Guide)
- Parent Involvement Success Kit (Planner + Strategy Guide + Video Training + Editable Templates + Membership Insider’s Guide)
- Family Events Binder Kit (Planner)
- Historian’s Binder Kit (Planner)
- Staff Appreciation Binder Kit (Planner)
- Vice President’s Binder Kit (Planner)
Purchasing the bundle saves 20% over buying the kits separately.
Get the kit here!
